The Problem of Loyalty: Lancaster Mennonites and the American Revolution

Eric Schubert

November 17, 2026

What did loyalty mean during the American Revolution? For many Americans, loyalty increasingly came to mean supporting the patriot cause, resisting British authority, and eventually embracing independence. For Lancaster County Mennonites, however, loyalty was much more complicated. Their religious convictions prohibited bearing arms and participating in warfare, yet the Revolution demanded visible demonstrations of political commitment. As neighbors enlisted, governments collected wartime taxes, and communities debated the meaning of patriotism, Mennonites had to determine how they could remain faithful to both their religious beliefs and the civil authorities under which they lived. Their story reveals that the Revolution was not only fought on battlefields. It also unfolded in meetinghouses, homes, and communities where people debated the relationship between faith, conscience, and citizenship.

In November 1775, Mennonite and German Baptist ministers from Lancaster County brought those questions directly to Pennsylvania’s government. They presented the Pennsylvania Assembly with a printed statement titled A Short and Sincere Declaration, explaining why members of their churches could not bear arms or participate in warfare. The declaration did not reject government authority or oppose the political changes taking place around them. Instead, the ministers argued that Christians should obey civil rulers while refusing actions that violated their religious commitments. Their statement offered one of the clearest explanations of how Mennonites understood loyalty during the Revolution—obedience to government, but not at the expense of conscience.[1]

Figure 1: A Short and Sincere Declaration, to Our Honorable Assembly, and all others in High or Low Station of Administration, and to all Friends and Inhabitants of This Country (Philadelphia, 1775). Mennonite and German Baptist ministers from Lancaster County presented this declaration to the Pennsylvania Assembly explaining why they could not bear arms while affirming obedience to civil government. Philadelphia: John Henry Miller, 1775. Courtesy of the Library of Congress, Rare Book and Special Collections Division.

Lancaster County was one of the largest centers of Mennonite settlement in eighteenth-century Pennsylvania. Families who had migrated from Swiss, Alsatian, and German-speaking regions of Europe established farms, built congregations, and created strong networks of mutual support throughout the county. Their faith shaped daily life through commitments to humility, simplicity, nonviolence, and separation from worldly power. Mennonites believed that Christians should not bear arms or participate in warfare, and many also discouraged oath-taking. At the same time, they were active members of Pennsylvania society. They purchased land, paid taxes, participated in local markets, and worked within colonial legal institutions. Their challenge during the Revolution was not whether to engage with the wider world, but how to do so without abandoning the religious principles that defined their communities.[2]

These tensions were not entirely new. Before the Revolution, Mennonites had already negotiated their place within Pennsylvania’s political system. Pennsylvania’s Quaker political tradition partly helped preserve exemptions for peace churches from compulsory military service, allowing Mennonites to maintain their religious commitments while participating in colonial society. They demonstrated loyalty through obedience to the law, payment of taxes, and support for their communities rather than through military service. The Revolution disrupted this arrangement. As Pennsylvania moved from colonial government toward independence, political leaders increasingly connected citizenship with public displays of support, creating new challenges for communities whose traditions emphasized religious rather than military expressions of loyalty.[3]

Those pressures became especially visible at the local level. Committees of Observation and Inspection organized patriot efforts, enforced economic restrictions, and investigated suspected opponents of the Revolutionary cause. In Lancaster County, decisions that had once been understood primarily as matters of religious conscience became public concerns. A Mennonite’s refusal to join the militia was no longer viewed simply as a personal religious decision. It could also be interpreted as a failure to support the new state. Although Mennonites generally did not identify as loyalists, their refusal to participate in military organizations and, for some, their refusal to renounce allegiance to the Crown, could lead patriot authorities and neighbors to regard them as politically suspect.[4] Quakers may be the closest similar scenario that historians have explored, as they generally rejected military service on religious grounds.

Taxes created another difficult compromise. Pennsylvania continued to recognize conscientious objections to military service, but exemption from bearing arms did not exempt Mennonites from the financial costs of war. Those who refused militia service often paid additional assessments connected to military obligations. County records show that non-associators contributed financially even while declining military participation.[5] For Mennonites, these payments represented an attempt to balance competing responsibilities. They could support their communities and obey civil authorities while still avoiding direct involvement in warfare. The Revolution, however, made that distinction increasingly difficult to maintain.

Figure 2: This map shows the geographic setting in which Lancaster County Mennonites negotiated questions of loyalty, military service, and religious conscience during the American Revolution. William Scull, Philadelphia, 1775. Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

Not all Mennonites agreed about where that boundary should be drawn. One disagreement that occurred broadly across Pennsylvania centered on Christian Funk, a bishop of the Franconia Mennonite Conference. Funk argued that supporting Pennsylvania’s Revolutionary government, including paying wartime taxes, was compatible with Mennonite faith because Christians could obey legitimate civil authority without personally bearing arms. Other Mennonite leaders disagreed, believing that even indirect support for war threatened the church’s historic commitment to nonresistance. The dispute resulted in Funk’s removal from the Mennonite community in 1778 and the creation of a separate group known as the Funkites.[6] The controversy shows that Mennonite responses to the Revolution were not simply acceptance or resistance. They involved serious debates over faith, government, and responsibility.

The Revolution also changed what it meant to be a loyal citizen. Pennsylvania’s Test Acts required residents to affirm allegiance to the new state government, creating another challenge for Mennonites whose traditions discouraged oath-taking. Those who refused could face restrictions on political participation, including voting and holding office.[7] Yet these restrictions did not remove Mennonites from Revolutionary society. They continued farming, producing goods, paying taxes, and supporting local communities affected by war. Their commitment to peace did not mean withdrawal from public life. Instead, they sought to participate in society while remaining faithful to their religious convictions.

The experience of Lancaster Mennonites reminds us that the Revolution was not simply a struggle between patriots and loyalists. Many people occupied a more complicated position. Mennonites did not embrace armed resistance, but they were not passive observers of the changes around them. They worked within their communities, negotiated with government officials, and struggled to define what loyalty meant in a rapidly changing world.

As Americans mark the 250th anniversary of the Revolution, the Mennonite experience offers an important reminder that the nation’s founding involved many different ideas about belonging. Some Americans expressed loyalty through military service and public declarations. Others expressed it through peaceful labor, community responsibility, and fidelity to religious conscience. Lancaster County Mennonites did not stand outside the Revolution. Their choices were part of the larger debate over what kind of nation the Revolution would create.


Endnotes 

[1]  A Short and Sincere Declaration, to Our Honorable Assembly, and all others in High or Low Station of Administration, and to all Friends and Inhabitants of This Country (Philadelphia, 1775), Evans Early American Imprints; Library of Congress Digital Collections. For broader historiographical context, see Jack D. Marietta, The Reformation of American Quakerism, 1748–1783 (Philadelphia, 2007); Eric R. Schlereth, An Age of Infidels: The Politics of Religious Controversy in the Early United States (Philadelphia, 2013); and Adam Jortner, A Promised Land: Jewish Patriots, the American Revolution, and the Birth of Religious Freedom (New York, 2024). These are just more recent examples demonstrating that Mennonites were not alone in facing pressure to reconcile religious conscience with revolutionary expectations. Quakers similarly encountered political suspicion because their pacifism and withdrawal from civil government could be interpreted as inadequate support for the Revolution. More recent scholarship has consequently moved beyond viewing religious communities simply as denominational subjects and increasingly examines how religious belief shaped broader questions of political allegiance, citizenship, participation, and religious liberty during and after the Revolution.

[2] Richard K. MacMaster, Samuel L. Horst, and Robert F. Ulle, Conscience in Crisis: Mennonites and Other Peace Churches in America, 1739–1789 (Scottdale, PA, 1979); John L. Ruth, ’Twas Seeding Time: A Mennonite View of the American Revolution (Scottdale, PA, 1976).

[3] Richard K. MacMaster, Samuel L. Horst, and Robert F. Ulle, Conscience in Crisis: Mennonites and Other Peace Churches in America, 1739–1789: Interpretation and Documents, Studies in Anabaptist and Mennonite History 20 (Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1979); Theron F. Schlabach, Peace, Faith, Nation: Mennonites and Amish in Nineteenth-Century America, The Mennonite Experience in America, vol. 2 (Scottdale, PA, 1988).

[4] Lancaster County Committee of Correspondence, Observation, and Inspection, Extracts from the Minutes of the Committee of Correspondence, Observation, and Inspection, for the County of Lancaster (Lancaster, PA, 1775–1776), Library of Congress, Printed Ephemera Collection.

[5] Lancaster County tax assessment records, 1777–1778, Pennsylvania State Archives.

[6] Joel Horst Nofziger, “The Funkite Schism and Mennonites During the American Revolution,” presentation, Mennonite Heritage Center, Harleysville, PA, May 7, 2026.

[7] Pennsylvania Test Acts and Oath of Allegiance statutes, 1777–1778, Statutes at Large of Pennsylvania.

Next Articles

The Whiff of Vinegar
Michael Nicholls offers insight into the kinds of digital records that aided his research for his recent JER article.
The Problem of Loyalty: Lancaster Mennonites and the American Revolution